Conversation
Jarkko Sakkinen
jarkko
Edited 15 days ago
It's weird that MCP even has its own dev summits. I can almost objectively say that it is good for nothing standard...
It's the other thing that LF pulled to its umbrella together with amazing Goose.
MCP server is a daemon and what clients do is that they query MCPs and fill out automatically some markdown bloat to their context. This is usually about 10-20 KiB per server and describe IPC shim. Then the client sends IPC on a tool call, which MCP then interprets that and makes the real call. It's an achievement to make this sloppy pipeline for executing a single action.
I've always felt that MCP was invented by vibecoding. You don't get this bad ideas elsewhere. Or like business idiot + prompt must have been where this has blossomed most likely.
It's the other thing that LF pulled to its umbrella together with amazing Goose.
MCP server is a daemon and what clients do is that they query MCPs and fill out automatically some markdown bloat to their context. This is usually about 10-20 KiB per server and describe IPC shim. Then the client sends IPC on a tool call, which MCP then interprets that and makes the real call. It's an achievement to make this sloppy pipeline for executing a single action.
I've always felt that MCP was invented by vibecoding. You don't get this bad ideas elsewhere. Or like business idiot + prompt must have been where this has blossomed most likely.
1
0
1
Just another piece that is also bad for security overall. I've posted a lot about AI but in order to build security that addresses agents I need to understand all the bad decisions AI industry has made :-) I think there should be a law for removing permit from AI researchers to write any software because they suck at it.
0
0
1